Deepest Differences: A Christian-Atheist Dialogue, By James W. Sire and Carl Peraino

Deepest Differences

A Christian-Atheist Dialogue

by James W. Sire and Carl Peraino

Deepest Differences
  • Length: 203 pages
  • Dimensions: 5.5 × 8.25 in
  • Published: March 03, 2009
  • Imprint: IVP
  • Item Code: 3358
  • ISBN: 9780830833580

*affiliate partner

If you're looking for clear-cut answers to difficult questions about God--or for your guy to score a quick knock-out of a toughened sparring partner--then this book is not for you.

But if you're open to an authentic, no-holds barred, respectful dialogue about one of life's most important issues, then take up and read. There are no straw men here.

Sparked by a chance meeting between two book-club acquaintances and their discussion of Kurt Vonnegut's obituary, this dialogue between long-time Christian Jim Sire and forthright atheist Carl Peraino developed through extended email exchanges exploring minds and brains, science and morality, faith and reason, God and violence, doubt and rhetoric.

You'll find much to ponder, weigh and explore in this lively, down-to-earth book. A study guide is included if you wish to delve deeper into any of the issues raised.

Both enlightening and entertaining. If you're open to an authentic, no-holds-barred, respectful dialogue between an inveterate nonbeliever and a confirmed believer about life's most important subject--God--then you will love it.

Jim Miller, Jim Miller Book Review, May 28, 2009


Editorial Note

Part One: Slipping into Dialogue
1. Mozart, Bach and Vonnegut: Signals of Transcendence
2. Signals Disallowed
3. Vonnegut: Humanist or Nihilist
4. Almost Human, Sometimes Smarter
5. Animal Morality

Part Two: From Morality to Worldview: The Argument Morphs
6. Morality, the Divine and Everything Else
7. An Objective Foundation for Morality
8. Scientists and Religious Commitment
9. A Colloquy on Morality

Part Three: The Theological Dimension: God in the Dock
10. Good and Evil and the Character of God
11. God Almighty
12. God, His Human Creation and Heavenly Bliss
13. God and Human Free Will
14. Speculation: What If? It Seems to Me . . .
15. Carl's Sabbath: A Personal Reflection

Part Four: Intelligent or Unintelligent Design
16. Scientists and Intelligent Design
17. Intelligent Design
18. Unintelligent Design
19. Passionately Antireligious
20. Jim's Sabbath: A Dizzy Dream

Part Five: Our Age: Sacred or Secular?
21. Remembering Secularism
22. Secularism Is Not Dead
23. In Defense of Novak

Part Six: Doctorow: The Power of Doubt
24. A Highly Evolved and Beautifully Stated Religious Point of View
25. An Unbridgeable Gulf
26. Doctorow Reconsidered
27. Doctorow: Pro and Con
28. Battling the Antitechnological Spirits
29. Computers Don't Forgive
30. Case Closed!

Part Seven: The God Question Once Again
32. Getting God Off the Hook
32. A Colloquy on the God Hypothesis
33. The Scandal of the Particular
34. A Believer's Crutch

Part Eight: Rats and Humans: Minds and Brains
35. Rat to Rat, Kindness Takes Hold
36. Chimps Too Are Kind
37. Show Me Kindness
38. Minds Emerge from Brains
39. Dualism Is Not Dead
40. Subtle Distinctions

Part Nine: The Source of Our Deepest Differences
41. A Change of Focus
42. A Way Forward
43. Carl and Jim in Ancient Greece
44. A Final Colloquy: On Faith and Reason

Part the Last: Winding Down
45. Enough Is Enough
46. Sure Is!

Afterword: Agreeing to Disagree
Carl's Comments
Jim's Comments
Study Guide
Relevant Readings
Subject Index


You May Also Like

James W. Sire

James W. Sire (1933–2018) was a widely respected apologist, author, and lecturer who served for more than thirty years as senior editor at InterVarsity Press. He is the author of over twenty books, including the seminal apologetics title The Universe Next DoorApologetics Beyond Reason, and Discipleship of the Mind.